Fashion Dilemma de Jour

I went shopping for the first time tonight since the 30 for 30 ended, and go figure, the first thing I buy are shoes. I seriously considered buying both these pairs. I didn't, but both are super cute! The brown are Lucky Brand and the black are Guess. I texted my friend pics and asked her which pair I should buy. I needed someone to intervene or else I would have walked out of the store spending more than I wanted. She said the brown. Which pair would you have gone with? Which pair do you think I ended up buying?